Home Scuba Diving Equipment 10 Best Scuba Diving Regulators For 2023 | Complete Buyer’s Guide

10 Best Scuba Diving Regulators For 2023 | Complete Buyer’s Guide

by 2 Dive For
47 minutes read

Table of Contents

How We Test

A good quality scuba diving regulator is crucial for a safe and enjoyable dive. With so many options on the market, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one.

That’s why we’ve created this buyer’s guide, where we’ve tested and evaluated the top recreational scuba regulators available in 2023. So, how did we test these regulators?

We started by conducting extensive research on each regulator’s features and specifications. We looked at the type of valve system (DIN or yoke), maximum operating depth, weight, and ease of use.

We also combed through customer reviews and scuba regulator FAQs to understand any common issues or concerns that divers may have with each model. After our initial research phase, we moved on to hands-on testing in controlled pool environments and open-water dives.

We wanted to evaluate how well each regulator performed in real-world conditions, including cold water temperatures and specific depths. We also paid close attention to factors like comfort level, ease of breathing, and overall durability.

Throughout this process, we took detailed notes about each regulator’s positive and negative performance, which informed our final rankings. In the following sections of this article, we’ll walk you through our top picks for the best overall scuba regulators in 2023 and the best mid-priced option, luxury/high-end choice, budget option travel regulator, and most durable model on the market today!

Keep in mind that there’s not a bad choice among these 10. There are positives and negatives for each. Your selection should be about budget and your needs. They’re all very good and come from very good companies.

I would HIGHLY recommend buying gear from an authorized scuba shop/dealer rather than from a warehouse store (You know, the one I’m talking about). The reason is that regulators usually need some assembly when purchased and sometimes tuning, depending on the manufacturer. An authorized dealer will give you the best service and a guaranteed best price. Please trust us; you’re asking for headaches buying any other way… We’re giving you links to our two favorite online dive shops. These are the only places I buy from.

Things to Consider

When buying a scuba regulator, there are several things you need to consider to ensure that you get the best regulator for your needs. You should remember some factors: Firstly, you must decide if you’re a vacation type diver or if you will dive 100 plus dives per year.

DIN regulators are more secure than yoke regulators and suitable for divers diving in cold water. On the other hand, yoke regulators are more common and used at most resorts.

Another factor is the weight of the scuba regulator. If you’re going on a dive trip, it’s important to choose a lightweight scuba regulator so that it won’t add extra weight to your luggage.

However, if you’re not worried about portability and prefer a heavy-duty model, then opt for one with durable materials such as stainless steel or titanium. You also need to consider your budget when choosing the best scuba regulator.

Some high-end models come with additional features such as adjustable breathing resistance and balanced diaphragm design, but they come at a premium price. Similarly, budget-friendly options offer reliable performance without breaking the bank.

If you have any specific requirements, such as needing a children’s scuba regulator or a mouthpiece for divers with dentures, mention them when purchasing your scuba regulator. These factors will help you buy the best scuba regulator for your needs and preferences!

Quick Look at the Top 10

Scroll down to see the full reviews.

Best Overall

Atomic B2 Regulator with Swivel

$849.95 At time of review

What we liked:

4.9 Out of 5
4.9/5
Atomic B2 Regulator Review - 1st and 2nd stage

For Recreational Diving, This might be the only regulator you need to buy. Yes, it’s that good.

Best Overall Runner Up

Scubapro MK25 EVO/S620 TI Regulator

$1159.00 At time of review

What we liked:

4.8 Out of 5
4.8/5
Scubapro MK25 EVOS620 Ti Regulator Review - 2nd Stage Front

This is a great regulator set. Overall quality and breathabilty make it a good 2nd place choice.

Best Luxury Regulator

Atomic TFX Regulator

$2,649.95 At time of review

What we liked:

4.9 Out of 5
4.9/5
Atomic TFX Regulator Review - 1st and 2nd stage

This is the best regulator I’ve ever tested. It’s amazing. It’s the easiest breathing.

If you can afford it, this is the regulator to own. You won’t be disappointed.

Runner Up Luxury Regulator

Scubapro MK25T EVO/S620 Ti

$2,759.00 At time of review

What we liked:

4.8 Out of 5
4.8/5
Scubapro MK25T EVOS620 Ti Regulator Review - 1st and 2nd stage

If you’re s ScubaPro fan, this is the way to go. All Titanium construction makes it very light. It’s incredibly easy to breathe at all depths and temperatures. The only reason it’s in 2nd in this category was the unique design of the Atomic TFX.

Best Budget Regulator

Sherwood Brut Pro Regulator

$364.95 At time of review

What we liked:

4.5 Out of 5
4.5/5
Sherwood Brut Pro Regulator Review - 1st and 2nd stage

You know you have a good regulator at a good price when so many dive shops use it as a rental option. It breathes very well at all depths thanks to it’s balanced 2nd stage.

If you’re getting started with scuba, this is a very nice choice.

Runner Up Budget Regulator

Zeagle Envoy II Regulator

$389.95 At time of review

What we liked:

4.5 Out of 5
4.5/5

As far as breathabilty, the two regulators in this category were very similar. They would both make good choices as part of your scuba rig. The only reason the Zeagle is in 2nd place is we felt the Sherwood felt more durable.

Best Travel Regulator

Cressi Compact Pro MC9 SC Regulator

$469.95 At time of review

What we liked:

4.5 Out of 5
4.5/5
Cressi XS Compact Pro MC9 SC Regulator Review - 1st and 2nd Stage

If you do a lot of diving while traveling, this would be a great choice to look at.

This was an incredibly tough category to judge. I’m quite sure you won’t be upset with either of them. They’re similar price, lightweight and easy to breath.

Runner Up Travel Regulator

Aqualung Titan Regulator

$475.00 At time of review

What we liked:

4.5 Out of 5
4.5/5
Aqualung Titan Regulator - 1st and 2nd stages

Great choice for a travel regulator. Either of the two regs in this category are a good decision.

Best Cold Water

Apeks XTX200 Regulator

$949.00 At time of review

What we liked:

4.5 Out of 5
4.5/5

If you like cold water environments, this is a solid choice!

Runner Up Cold Water

Mares Abyss 22 Navy II Regulator

$997.95 At time of review

What we liked:

4.5 Out of 5
4.5/5
Mares Abyss 22 Navy II Regulator Review - 1st and 2nd stages

This is a great regulator set. Overall quality and breathabilty make it a good 2nd place choice.

Best Overall Regulator - Our #1 Choice

Atomic B2 Regulator with Swivel

Review Summary:

Emerging as our top pick among the scuba diving regulators we’ve reviewed, the Atomic B2 Regulator by Atomic Aquatics sets the bar high with its superior quality and performance. This regulator is a paragon of versatility, offering both DIN and yoke valve options, and is designed with an over-balanced diaphragm first stage and a pneumatically balanced second stage. These features ensure consistent and enhanced breathability, making it a reliable companion in various diving environments. The Atomic B2 Regulator also stands out with its ample hose routing and accessory attachment options, thanks to its two high-pressure and five low-pressure ports. Although it comes with a higher price tag, its exceptional build quality and performance make it a valuable investment for divers who won’t settle for anything less than the best.

Atomic B2 Regulator Overall Review - Quick Look

After diving deep into testing and gathering insights from experts and fellow divers, we’ve got the inside scoop. Here’s what we think in a nutshell. Continue scrolling to read the rest of the review.

4.8

4.8/5

Do we recommend this regulator? Yes

Likes

Dislikes

It’s always advisable to buy regulators from an authorized dealer so they can be set up and tested before use. Click on either of the buttons below.

Runner Up - Best Overall Regulator

Scubapro MK25 EVO/S600

Review Summary:

The Scubapro MK25 EVO/S600 is a top-tier scuba diving regulator known for its exceptional performance and reliability. Comprising two main components, the MK25 EVO first stage, and the S600 second stage, this regulator delivers smooth and consistent airflow, catering to recreational and professional divers. It features a balanced diaphragm valve for excellent breathing performance at various depths, and the first stage showcases Scubapro’s commitment to quality with its corrosion-resistant materials. The second stage is ergonomically designed for comfort and ease of use, with a high-quality downstream valve for smooth breathing. Despite its slightly heavier weight, the MK25 EVO/S600 regulator offers sturdy and robust construction, inspiring confidence in its durability. While it comes with a higher price tag, its exceptional build, breathability, and reliability make it a great value for divers prioritizing top-notch equipment.

Scubapro MK25 EVO/S600 Regulator Review - Quick Look

After diving deep into testing and gathering insights from experts and fellow divers, we’ve got the inside scoop. Here’s what we think in a nutshell. Continue scrolling to read the rest of the review.

4.7

4.7/5

Do we recommend this regulator? Yes

Likes

Dislikes

It’s always advisable to buy regulators from an authorized dealer so they can be set up and tested before use. Click on either of the buttons below.

Best Luxury Regulator

Atomic TFX Regulator

Review Summary:

The Atomic TFX Regulator, a masterpiece from Atomic Aquatics, sets a new standard in the realm of luxury scuba diving equipment. With its innovative design, where the inhalation diaphragm and exhaust valve are uniquely positioned at the front, the TFX – short for Titanium Front Exhaust – offers unparalleled breathability and dryness. This regulator, which is available in both DIN and yoke valve options, features a balanced flow-through piston in the first stage and a downstream demand valve in the second stage. It has proven its exceptional breathability and air delivery in various testing conditions, earning it the title of the best breathing regulator we’ve tested. Despite its premium status and price tag, the Atomic TFX Regulator’s innovative design, high-quality materials, and superior performance make it the best luxury regulator on the market, and a compelling investment for serious divers. If not for its price, it would undoubtedly take the top spot in our overall rankings.

Atomic TFX Regulator Review - Quick Look

After diving deep into testing and gathering insights from experts and fellow divers, we’ve got the inside scoop. Here’s what we think in a nutshell. Continue scrolling to read the rest of the review.

4.9

4.9/5

Do we recommend this regulator? Yes

Likes

Dislikes

It’s always advisable to buy regulators from an authorized dealer so they can be set up and tested before use. Click on either of the buttons below.

Best Luxury Regulator - Runner Up

Scubapro MK25T EVO/S620 Ti Regulator

Review Summary:

The Scubapro MK25T EVO/S620 Ti Regulator is a testament to Scubapro’s dedication to superior quality and innovative design in scuba diving equipment. Crafted from a single block of titanium, this regulator showcases an impressive resistance to both corrosion and freezing, ensuring reliable performance even under the most challenging conditions. It features a balanced flow-through piston in the first stage and an air-balanced valve in the second stage, both of which contribute to its exceptional breathability and consistent air delivery. Despite being a premium product with a higher price point, the Scubapro MK25T EVO/S620 Ti Regulator offers significant value to divers who prioritize durability and top-tier performance in their diving gear.

Scubapro MK25T EVO/S620 Ti Regulator Review - Quick Look

After diving deep into testing and gathering insights from experts and fellow divers, we’ve got the inside scoop. Here’s what we think in a nutshell. Continue scrolling to read the rest of the review.

4.8

4.8/5

Do we recommend this regulator? Yes

Likes

Dislikes

It’s always advisable to buy regulators from an authorized dealer so they can be set up and tested before use. Click on either of the buttons below.

Best Budget Regulator

Sherwood Brut Pro Regulator

Review Summary:

The Sherwood Brut Pro Regulator, a product of Sherwood Scuba’s dedication to quality and innovation, offers a dependable and smooth diving experience for enthusiasts of all levels. This regulator is designed to withstand the demands of recreational diving, offering consistent performance across various conditions and depths. Crafted with a mechanically balanced flow-by-piston first stage and a pneumatically balanced second stage, it ensures impressive breathability and air delivery. While some divers have noted its slightly heavier weight, the Brut Pro’s reliability and performance are widely praised. As an entry-level regulator, it offers excellent value for money, making it a popular choice for rental programs and a trusted backup for many instructors. Despite its affordability, it doesn’t compromise on durability or efficiency, making it a commendable choice for recreational divers.

Sherwood Brut Pro Regulator Review - Quick Look

After diving deep into testing and gathering insights from experts and fellow divers, we’ve got the inside scoop. Here’s what we think in a nutshell. Continue scrolling to read the rest of the review.

4.5

4.5/5

Do we recommend this regulator? Yes

Likes

Dislikes

It’s always advisable to buy regulators from an authorized dealer so they can be set up and tested before use. Click on either of the buttons below.

Best Budget Regulator - Runner Up

Zeagle Envoy II Regulator

Review Summary:

The Zeagle Envoy II Regulator emerges as a prominent choice in the world of scuba diving equipment, offering a blend of comfort, reliability, and performance that caters to the needs of recreational divers. This regulator, a product of Zeagle’s innovative design approach, features a balanced diaphragm in both the first and second stages, ensuring consistent breathability and air delivery across a range of diving conditions. While its weight might be noticeable during extended dives, the regulator’s overall performance and the flexibility offered by its multiple low-pressure ports have earned it positive feedback from the diving community. Despite its competitive pricing, the Zeagle Envoy II Regulator does not compromise on quality, making it a commendable choice for those seeking a reliable and enjoyable diving experience.

Zeagle Envoy II Regulator Review - Quick Look

After diving deep into testing and gathering insights from experts and fellow divers, we’ve got the inside scoop. Here’s what we think in a nutshell. Continue scrolling to read the rest of the review.

4.5

4.5/5

Do we recommend this regulator? Yes

Likes

Dislikes

It’s always advisable to buy regulators from an authorized dealer so they can be set up and tested before use. Click on either of the buttons below.

Best Travel Regulator

Cressi XS Compact Pro MC9 SC Regulator

Review Summary:

The Cressi XS Compact Pro MC9 SC Regulator, a product of the renowned Italian manufacturer Cressi, is a compact and robust scuba diving regulator that delivers reliable performance under various conditions. This regulator, our top pick for travel, is engineered to provide smooth and comfortable breathing, making it an ideal choice for divers at all skill levels. It features a balanced diaphragm in both the first and second stages, ensuring consistent airflow even at greater depths and colder temperatures. While the price point may be slightly higher than some entry-level regulators, the quality, performance, and longevity of the Cressi XS Compact Pro MC9 SC justify the investment. Its lightweight design, combined with its reliable performance, makes it an excellent travel companion for divers seeking a regulator that can grow with their experience.

Cressi XS Compact Pro MC9 SC Regulator Review - Quick Look

After diving deep into testing and gathering insights from experts and fellow divers, we’ve got the inside scoop. Here’s what we think in a nutshell. Continue scrolling to read the rest of the review.

4.5

4.5/5

Do we recommend this regulator? Yes

Likes

Dislikes

It’s always advisable to buy regulators from an authorized dealer so they can be set up and tested before use. Click on either of the buttons below.

Best Travel Regulator - Runner Up

Aqualung Titan Regulator

Review Summary:

The Aqualung Titan Regulator, a product of the esteemed brand, is a robust and innovative scuba diving regulator that offers reliable performance in various conditions. This regulator, our runner-up in the best travel regulator category, is designed with precision and durability, ensuring smooth and comfortable breathing for divers of all experience levels. It features a balanced diaphragm in the first stage and an unbalanced downstream demand valve in the second, delivering consistent airflow across different conditions and depths. While some divers have noted its weight as a potential concern for travel, the Titan’s performance and sturdy construction more than compensate for this minor drawback. Despite its budget-friendly price point, the Aqualung Titan Regulator does not compromise on quality, making it an excellent value for divers seeking a reliable and high-performing travel regulator.

Aqualung Titan Regulator Review - Quick Look

After diving deep into testing and gathering insights from experts and fellow divers, we’ve got the inside scoop. Here’s what we think in a nutshell. Continue scrolling to read the rest of the review.

4.6

4.6/5

Do we recommend this regulator? Yes

Likes

Dislikes

It’s always advisable to buy regulators from an authorized dealer so they can be set up and tested before use. Click on either of the buttons below.

Best Cold Water Regulator

Apeks XTX200 Regulator

Review Summary:

The Apeks XTX200 Regulator, a flagship offering from the esteemed British manufacturer Apeks, is a testament to the brand’s commitment to quality, innovation, and performance. This regulator, which we’ve recognized as the best cold water regulator we’ve tested, is precision-engineered to provide exceptional breathability and stability across all depths and temperatures. It features an over-balanced diaphragm in the first stage and a pneumatically balanced downstream demand valve in the second stage, ensuring smooth and reliable airflow in various diving conditions. While some divers have noted its weight as a potential drawback, the XTX200’s superior performance and robust build quality more than make up for it. Despite its premium price point, the Apeks XTX200 Regulator offers excellent value, making it a worthwhile investment for divers seeking a high-performing, durable, and reliable regulator for their cold water dives.

Apeks XTX200 Regulator Review - Quick Look

After diving deep into testing and gathering insights from experts and fellow divers, we’ve got the inside scoop. Here’s what we think in a nutshell. Continue scrolling to read the rest of the review.

4.5

4.6/5

Do we recommend this regulator? Yes

Likes

Dislikes

It’s always advisable to buy regulators from an authorized dealer so they can be set up and tested before use. Click on either of the buttons below.

Best Cold Water Regulator - Runner Up

Mares Abyss 22 Navy II

Review Summary:

The Mares Abyss 22 Navy II Regulator, a standout offering from the trusted manufacturer Mares, is a robust and versatile piece of scuba diving equipment that excels in various environments, including extreme conditions. This regulator, recognized as the runner-up in the best cold water regulator category, is renowned for its high performance, durability, and dependability in colder waters. It features a balanced diaphragm in the first stage and a downstream demand valve in the second stage, ensuring smooth and reliable airflow in various diving conditions. While some divers have noted its weight as a potential drawback, the Abyss 22 Navy II’s superior performance and robust build quality make up for it. Despite its premium price point, the Mares Abyss 22 Navy II Regulator offers excellent value. It is a worthwhile investment for divers seeking a high-performing, durable, and reliable regulator for their cold water dives.

Mares Abyss 22 Navy II Regulator Review - Quick Look

After diving deep into testing and gathering insights from experts and fellow divers, we’ve got the inside scoop. Here’s what we think in a nutshell. Continue scrolling to read the rest of the review.

4.5

4.5/5

Do we recommend this regulator? Yes

Likes

Dislikes

It’s always advisable to buy regulators from an authorized dealer so they can be set up and tested before use. Click on either of the buttons below.

You may also like

Leave a Comment